There are standard guidelines that all caregivers use to make the
diagnosis of Attention Deficit/ Hyperactivity Disorder. These guidelines are
published in a manual called the “Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders” (DSM). In 2013, a new, 5th edition of the DSM was
published.
At first, there was criticism that the new manual loosened the criterion
for making the diagnosis of ADHD. The concern came from a commonly-stated fear
that ADHD is already over-diagnosed and over-treated. But the new diagnostic
guidelines are only minimally different from the previous guidelines. The same
questions are asked about inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity – the main
symptoms used to diagnose ADHD. With the old guidelines, we asked if any of
these symptoms were present before age 7. The new guidelines liberalize that
slightly by saying “before age 12”. They also require that “several” of the
symptoms are present in more than one setting – school, home, or other settings
outside the home. The only change that made the diagnosis of ADHD “easier” was
that less criterion were required to make the diagnosis of ADHD in adults. This makes sense because some of the
ADHD symptoms are different in adults –for example, there is less
hyperactivity.
Because the diagnosis of ADHD is still made from a child’s history
rather than using a “test”, it is important that caregivers have clearly outlined diagnostic
criteria. Having standard guidelines that we all can
refer to helps to ease parents’ concerns about over-diagnosis. It is important
for parents to have confidence in a caregiver’s diagnosis of ADHD because
untreated ADHD can result in to school failure, depression, drug abuse and
suicide.
Other recent studies have repeated the previously known facts that ADHD
is not a dietary deficiency, food allergy or simply “a behavior problem.”
Agreement was also reached that there is no connection between the use of ADHD
medication and sudden death in children from heart problems (another commonly
stated fear). The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that any child with
ADHD have a thorough medical history review which includes the family cardiac
history, but it does not recommend that caregivers obtain an electrocardiogram
(EEG) in a child before starting ADHD medication.
There is one new test that might make the diagnosis of ADHD easier. In
2013, the FDA approved for marketing a specialized measurement of brain waves
called the Neuropsychiatric EEG-Based Assessment System. This is a test that
measures certain types of brain waves that seem to be more common in children
with ADHD. Whether or not this test will finally offer a “more scientific” way
of making the diagnosis of ADHD remains to be seen.
No comments:
Post a Comment