There are times when a child needs an X-Ray but there are many more
times when unnecessary X-rays are done. X-ray examinations cause exposure to
radiation that accumulates over a child’s lifetime and causes an increased risk
of cancer with every exposure. A child’s body is also more susceptible to the
effects of radiation.
Unnecessary X-ray studies are done for many reasons, but they are often done
to confirm a diagnosis that can be made by physical examination alone. Often,
the parents are the ones who insist on the study being done and the doctor
complies because of the risk of a lawsuit. The child hits his head and may even
have a mild concussion. The doctor can explain to the parents about the signs
of an internal hemorrhage and instruct them on what to watch for but the
parents often want a CAT scan “to be sure”. The doctor may not feel the CAT
scan is necessary, but will get it to avoid “missing” a small hemorrhage. A CAT
scan is now routinely done to diagnose appendicitis before any surgeon will
agree to operate. The frequent use
of CAT scans in children is especially worrisome because CAT scans involve much
higher doses of radiation than regular X-rays. Fluoroscopy also involves more
radiation than standard X-rays and should only be done when absolutely
necessary. Even with regular X-rays, doses of radiation designed for adults are
often used when much lower doses would be sufficient for children.
A doctor may get an X-ray of a fractured clavicle (collar bone) even though
the history and physical exam clearly make the diagnosis and there is no
treatment necessary. A doctor may make the diagnosis of pneumonia in a child
who is not in any respiratory distress but feel an X-ray is necessary “to be
sure”. Again, with proper
instruction on what symptoms to observe for, the X-ray doesn’t change either
the diagnosis or the treatment.
The FDA has recently asked manufacturers of imaging devices to create
new machines designed specifically with children in mind. Radiology departments
are developing protocols designed for children with smaller doses of radiation
and limited areas of body exposure. Parents need to discuss the advantages and
disadvantages of any X-ray with their doctor. They should always ask: “Is the
result of the X-ray going to change the way we are going to treat the
problem?”; “If we watch the child closely for any developing symptoms, can we
hold off doing the X-ray as long as we agree to get it if the situation
changes?”
An X-ray examination is simple and can be reassuring, but parents and
physicians need to always consider the risk and ask if the study is necessary.